I am a self-proclaimed American Idol junkie. I'm not joking. When Idol premiere night comes around every January, it's like a second coming of Christmas. Just plain joyous. I don't know what it is - the competition factor, Simon Cowell, the music, picking my favorites and defending them to no end ... I don't know. I just love it all. I've watched since the very first season, and it hasn't gotten old at all.
But wow. This seasons blows.
After watching Hollywood Week, I was like, 'Wow this could be a really great season.' The top 24 appeared to have some measure of talent. Then we all found out they a) are mediocre b) can't perform and c) cannot for the life of them pick the right song.
They pick boring songs. Really boring songs that don't allow them to do much at all. No 'wow' factors. Nothing that sets them apart from each other. People have been saying it's all karaoke. They're right, and they might as well just get drunk beforehand because at least it would be entertaining. And then there's Kara DioGuardi. The most annoying judge in Idol history. You love to hear yourself talk, we get it. You love Simon, we get it. You are really good at song-writing. Stick to that.
Let's break down the contestants:
Aaron Kelly: Justin Bieber comes to mind when I see him. Obviously he's not as cool as Justin Bieber because he has yet to do a song with Ludacris, but there's time yet. He's only 16; I tend to have biases against 16 year-old contestants, but this kid is alright. He has a good voice. He's from close to my hometown. Upside: Justin Bieber is huge right now. He can tap into that demographic. Downside: He's like 12.
Andrew Garcia: a.k.a the guy who did an awesome version of Paula Abdul's 'Straight Up.' Since then? Nothing much at all. I love this guy's voice, don't get me wrong. He just hasn't been very entertaining. That said, he's likeable. Why wouldn't you like this guy? I mean his dad cries everytime he talks about him. He's got a hot wife and an adorable kid. Upside: He's just plain cool. Downside: I'm bored.
Casey James: Lord have mercy. By far the season's best looking candidate. Those blue eyes. His blonde hair. I don't even like long hair on guys, but I like his long hair. The bottom line is, he won't win this competition. He reminds me of an Ace Young (except he can play a mean guitar so that's a one-up on Ace) -- dreamy guy without really strong vocals. I love his voice. He's my favorite. But I don't think this is the place for him. Prove me wrong please. Upside: He's hot and plays guitar. Downside: He won't wow you too often.
Crystal Bowersox: This chick is going to win, and I'm going to be pissed. Actually I dont' know if she'll win, but she's the only one left who is an 'artist.' The judges kiss her ass just about every week. She's not bad. She knows who she is as a musician ... and she seems really nice. But she is NOT the American Idol. She just isn't. Yeah, I'm shallow when it comes to this show. I admit it. But when I see her (and listen to her song choices) I think: old. Adult contemporary. Not Idol. Upside: She's probably the only legit one on the show. Downside: Old. Can't be made over. (Sorry that's mean)
Didi Benami: Ah whatever. I don't hate her. I don't love her. She was probably in the top two most boring people until Rolling Stones week when she rocked it. I like her voice, but nowadays it's not really that original. We have the Duffy's, the Adele's, the Ingrid's. She's cool, but I wouldn't buy her album unless she has a killer single. I already have the other sound-alikes' music. Upside: None. Downside: None.
Katie Stevens: She has one of my favorite voices. But she is so annoying. I think it's the 16 year-old thing. She's kind of like a Miley Cyrus but with an actual singing voice. Anyway compared to everyone else, I kind of like her. She's a younger version of Katharine McPhee. Upside: Chances are she can sing 'Over the Rainbow' acapella whille sitting in a gown on the floor. Downside: Don't speak.
Lee Dewyze: I like this kid. I like his voice. When he sang Hinder he sounded identical to Austin Winkler. His problem? NO PERSONALITY. None. Who are you??? He sings, he stands here, gives a half smile, then goes and sits down. I mean, you can tell he's genuine. He's not trying to be something he's not. But you have so much potential buddy!! Get some personality. It will help your performances so, so much. Upside: Unique. Downside: Zero personality will hurt him in the end.
Michael Lynche: Maybe the most likeable person in the competition this year. Big loveable Teddy Bear. Feels like we know him - considering we saw the birth of his child and all. The only problem I have with him is that it's nothing we haven't heard before. I don't see him being extremely popular post-Idol, should he win. Upside: Likeability. Downside: He can sing, but so can a lot of people.
Siobhan Magnus: The best remaining girl. I like her voice a lot. It's clear, and she can definitely belt a note (see her rendition of 'Think') -- then again her 'belting' gets a little too screamy for me sometimes. I can see her sticking around for awhile because she's quite a bit more talented than some of the other contestants. Upside: True talent. Downside: She is so weird.
Tim Urban: Umm ... he has a nice smile? He could be the fourth Jonas brother? Have you seen him talk? He's like a Disney character. He's gotta be next to go. I don't hate the kid, but I'm pretty sure everyone is officially better than him. Upside: Plays into the hearts of teenage girls. Downside: He's not that great at all.
The eliminated: Lacey Brown should have went about four weeks ago after she butchered Stevie Nicks. That was the last straw for me. I do think Paige Miles deserved to stay there longer than she did. She had a solid voice -- not to mention even when she had laryngitis.
I honestly cannot even predict a winner because I don't think any of them should win. As much as it pains me to say it, I'm ready to focus on Simon's X Factor. I just have some requests: take Ryan Seacrest with you. He's brilliant at what he does. I wouldn't even be opposed to taking Randy. I'd be interested to see how he mentors. And whatever you do please leave Kara at home.